Hearth Interactive

The Plague Comes to Messina and Catania

Written
after April 1348 (events of October 1347 to April 1348)
Place
Messina and Catania, Sicily
Language
Latin
Kind of source
chronicle
Reading time
13 minutes
Difficulty
Moderate
Intensity
High: symptoms described in detail, abandoned sick and unburied dead

Black Death (1347–1351)Plague (Yersinia pestis)ChristianityDeath and burialFamily and loss

Once in a Lifetime themes: Fear, Blame, Unknowns

Versions

The edited translation, in simplified modern English. Bracketed words were added for clarity; [...] marks a cut. Tap a note number to read the note.

The galleys reach Messina

The Sicilians were overjoyed at this peace.1 Living at peace at last, they praised God for so great a gift, one the kings of Sicily before them had never been able to win. Then a deadly plague broke out all over the island of Sicily. This is how it happened. In the year of the Lord’s Incarnation 1347, at the beginning of October, in the first indiction,2 twelve Genoese galleys put in at the port of the city of Messina.3 They were fleeing the vengeance of God, which our Lord had sent down on them for their sins.4 They brought with them a disease so fixed in their bones that anyone who had spoken with one of them caught a deadly sickness at once. He could in no way escape death.

These were the signs of death in the Genoese and in the people of Messina who mixed with them. As they talked together, their breath carried the infection,5 and one person infected another. The sick man seemed shaken all over with pain, almost shattered. From this pain and the infected breath a lentil-shaped pustule rose near the thigh or the arm. It so infected and penetrated the body that the sick spat blood violently. They spat for three days without stopping, and no treatment could cure them. Then they breathed their last. And not only did everyone who talked with them die, but anyone who bought, touched, or sought out their belongings.

When the people of Messina realized that this sudden death had come on them because of the Genoese galleys, they drove the Genoese out of the port and the city as fast as they could. But the sickness stayed in the city, and a great mortality followed. People came to loathe one another so much that if a son fell sick with the disease, his father would not stay with him. If the father dared to go near him, he caught the disease himself and could not escape death. Within three days he breathed his last. And he did not die alone. Everyone in his household who stood by him, even the dogs and the animals in the house, followed the head of the family in death.

The mortality grew so strong in Messina that many people asked to confess their sins to a priest and to make their wills. But priests, judges, and notaries refused to come to their houses. Any who did go into their homes to draw up wills and the like could not escape sudden death. Friars of the Order of Minors, of the Preachers, and of other orders were willing to go to the homes of the sick.6 They heard their confessions and gave them penance according to [...] divine justice.7 But death struck them down so hard that hardly any of them were left in their cells.

What more is there to say? Corpses lay alone in their own houses. No priest, son, father, or other relative dared to go in. Instead they paid porters good money to carry the bodies to burial. The houses of the dead stood wide open, with all their jewels, money, and valuables. Anyone who wished could walk in, and no one stopped him. The pestilence came on so suddenly and so strongly that at first there were not enough servants and attendants, and then there were none at all.

Seeing this terrible and monstrous thing, the people of Messina chose to leave the city rather than die. No one was allowed into the city, or even near it. They set up homes with their families on the threshing floors and in the vineyards outside the walls. But most went on to the city of Catania. They trusted that the blessed virgin Agatha of Catania would free them from the sickness.8

Queen Elisabeth of Sicily was in the city of Catania. She sent for her son Don Frederick, who was in Messina at the time, to come to her at once.9 He hurried to Catania on Venetian galleys.

Saint Agatha's relics

Many of the people of Messina who were now in Catania presented a devout petition to the lord Patriarch.10 With one voice they begged him to go to Messina himself, out of devotion and with fitting honor, taking some of the relics of the virgin Agatha. “For we believe,” they said, “that when these relics come, the city of Messina will be wholly freed from this sickness.” The Patriarch was moved by their prayers and agreed to take the relics to Messina himself. This was in the year of the Lord 1347, toward the end of November, in the first indiction.

But the holy virgin Agatha saw the hidden deceit and the plots of the Messinese, who had always aimed at her like archers at a target.11 They meant to keep her relics at Messina. But the Lord went to work, moved by prayers offered through her. All the common people of Catania went to the Patriarch shouting that they would not stand for it. They seized the keys from the keeper of the shrine and rebuked the Patriarch fiercely. They would rather die, they said, than let the relics go to Messina. Faced with this rebuke, the Patriarch could do nothing else. With church chants and great devotion, he entered the place where the relics were kept, with the choir of monks and holy prayers. He dipped some of the holy relics in clean water and ordered the holy water to be taken to Messina. He sailed there with it himself.

What more is there to say? When the Patriarch landed at Messina with the holy water, he sprinkled many different sick people with it, made the sign of the cross over them, and freed them from the sickness. The people of Messina came running to him. They hurried to see him with great joy and gave many thanks to him and to God. For demons had been appearing in the city in the shape of dogs, doing great harm to people’s bodies.12 The people were so terrified that no one dared to leave the house.

All the same, with everyone’s agreement and by the wish of the archbishop of Messina, they decided to go in procession around the city, chanting litanies. While all the people were going in, a black dog appeared among them, carrying a drawn sword in its hand. Snarling, it rushed at them. It broke all the silver vessels, lamps, and candlesticks on the altars and smashed them to pieces. At the sight, everyone fell on their faces, half dead with fear. After a while they found their strength again and got up. They saw the dog leaving the church, and no one dared to follow it or go near it.

The Virgin of the Scala

The people of Messina were terrified by this strange sight, and fear gripped them all. So they decided to walk together barefoot, in a procession led by priests, to the blessed Virgin of the Scala, six miles from the city.13 As they came near the Virgin’s church, they all knelt on the ground together, weeping and crying out for help from God and the blessed Virgin. They went into the church with devout prayers, chanting with the priests, “Have mercy on us, O God.” Then with their own hands they took up a carved image of the Mother of God that had stood there since ancient times. They decided to bring it into Messina. They believed that when the image was seen in the city and entered it, it would drive out the demons and free them from the mortality.

They chose a worthy priest to carry the image with honor in his arms, riding on a horse. As they came back toward Messina with the image, the holy Mother of God saw the city and drew near it. She found it so hateful, so stained with the blood of its sins, that she turned her back on it. Not only would she not enter the city; she could not bear to look at it. At that the earth split open deep down. The horse carrying the image of the Mother of God stood fixed like a rock and could neither go forward nor back. When the people of Messina saw these miracles, they wailed and sighed and wept. They begged the blessed Virgin not to take fresh vengeance on them for the sins they had committed. Moved by their humble prayers, the Virgin, holy bride of Christ, carried their petitions to the Lord. The earth that had opened closed again, and the horse walked on. But when it reached the city gate, the holy Mother of God still refused to go in. At last, after many devout prayers to her, she entered the great church of Messina, Saint Mary la Nova.14 The women of Messina covered the image with silk cloths and precious jewels.

Flight from Messina

[...] What more is there to say? The coming of the image did no good at all. The mortality raged worse than ever, so that no one could help anyone else. Most of the citizens deserted Messina. Some scattered into Calabria, others to different parts of Sicily, above all to the city of Catania.15 But what good was running away? The sickness had already taken hold and was eating at their bodies. Some fell dead as they fled, on the road, in the fields, on the shore, at sea, in the village of Mascali,16 in the woods and valleys, and in all sorts of wretched places.

Those who reached the city of Catania breathed their last in lodging houses. So many people from Messina died in Catania that the citizens asked the Patriarch to act. He ordered, on pain of excommunication, that no one from Messina was to be buried inside the city. They were to be buried outside, in very deep graves.17 What more is there to say? People found them so loathsome and so frightening that no one would speak to them or keep company with them. Everyone ran from the sight of them and would not breathe their breath. They became a laughingstock to all of Catania. If one of them spoke to anyone, the answer came back in the common speech: Non mi parlari, ca si Missinisi.18 No one would give them lodging. They could find no house to rent anywhere. Some people from Messina who lived in Catania with their families took them in secretly. Without them, they would have had almost no help at all.

So the people of Messina scattered over the whole island of Sicily. When they reached the city of Syracuse, the sickness struck the people there and killed many, a vast number. The towns of Xacca and Trapani and the city of Agrigento shared Messina’s pestilence as well.19 Trapani above all was left almost empty of people.

The mortality at Catania

And what shall we say of the city of Catania, which has been left out of this account? The plague grew so strong there that not only did the pustules appear that people called antrachi,20 but also swellings in different parts of the body: some in the groin, others on the legs, others on the arms, others on the throat. At first the swellings were the size of hazelnuts, and they came on with violent shivering. They so wasted and tormented the body that the sick could no longer stand and took to their beds, burning with high fevers and in great distress. Then the swellings grew to the size of a walnut, then of a hen’s egg or a goose egg. The great pain and the rotting of the humors21 forced the sick to spit blood. This spittle came up from the infected lung to the throat and made the whole body rot. With the body rotted and its humors failing, they breathed their last. The sickness lasted three days. By the fourth day at the latest, they had left the world of the living.

The people of Catania saw how quickly the sickness ran its course. As soon as they felt a headache and shivering, they confessed all their sins to a priest, first of all, and then had their wills made. The mortality in the city grew so thick that the judges and notaries refused to go and draw up wills. If they did go to a sick person, they stood far away from him. The priests were so afraid of death that they shrank from going to the houses of the sick at all. The mortality in the city was so great that the judges and notaries could not keep up with the wills, nor the priests with the confessions. The Patriarch wanted to provide for the souls of Catania. So he gave every priest, however lowly, all the power he himself held, as bishop and as patriarch, to absolve sins.22 As a result, all who died were surely received, as the true faith teaches, into the safe place of God.

The death of Duke John

Duke John feared this death.23 He would not go near cities or inhabited places because the air there was infected,24 so he kept moving from place to place through the woods and wild country. He went here and there, as if in hiding: now to the spring of Mili in the woods of Catania, now to a tower called lu Blancu, six miles from the city, now to the church of San Salvatore de Blanchardu, in the woods of Catania. At last he came to a church and estate he had recently built, called Sanctu Andria, on the edge of the woods of Mascali. He was well and unharmed there, until a sickness came on him and he died. His body was buried in the cathedral of Catania, in the same tomb where the body of his father, the late King Frederick, had been laid to rest.25 This was in April, in the year of the Lord 1348, in the first indiction.

This mortality lasted from September of the first indiction until about the time of the duke’s death, a little before or after. It was a heavy mortality. It spared neither sex and no age. It [...] everyone, without stopping.26 Even those it did not kill, it left drained and broken by a foul wasting. In this mortality the Patriarch died too. He was buried in the cathedral of Catania. May his soul rest in peace.

Notes

  1. The peace between Sicily and Queen Joanna I of Naples, signed on November 7, 1347, after long years of war between their kingdoms. The pope never ratified it. back
  2. Years counted in the fifteen-year cycle of the indiction, which in Sicily began each September 1. The first indiction here ran from September 1, 1347, to August 31, 1348. back
  3. Genoa, in northern Italy, was a city-republic whose merchants traded across the Mediterranean and the Black Sea. Messina, in northeastern Sicily, guarded the strait between Sicily and the mainland. back
  4. The belief that God sent disease to punish wrongdoing. The chronicler does not say what the Genoese had done. back
  5. The idea that disease passed from person to person by breath, touch, or objects, long before anyone knew about germs. back
  6. The Friars Minor (Franciscans) and the Order of Preachers (Dominicans), orders of friars who lived among townspeople, preached, and heard confessions. back
  7. The printed text has a gap here, marked by a row of dots. back
  8. Agatha, an early Christian martyr, was the patron saint of Catania, where her relics were kept. Catania lies about 55 miles (90 km) south of Messina. back
  9. Elisabeth of Carinthia, widow of King Peter II. Her son Frederick, born in 1342, later reigned as Frederick IV. Her elder son Louis, still a boy, was king. back
  10. Gerard Odonis, a Franciscan and former head of his order, held the title of Latin Patriarch of Antioch and ran the church of Catania for the pope from 1342. back
  11. The Latin echoes Lamentations 3:12, “he set me as a mark for the arrow.” It may instead mean that the people of Messina had always been Agatha’s target. back
  12. Many medieval Christians believed that demons, evil spirits, could cause illness and could appear in the shape of animals or people. back
  13. The shrine of Santa Maria della Scala, in a valley in the hills outside Messina. It was a house of nuns, abandoned after the plague. back
  14. Santa Maria la Nuova, the cathedral of Messina. back
  15. Calabria, the toe of mainland Italy, across the strait from Messina. back
  16. Mascali, on the coast north of Catania, below Mount Etna, then surrounded by woodland. back
  17. Excommunication, the penalty for anyone who broke this order, cut a person off from the church and its sacraments. back
  18. Sicilian for “Don’t talk to me, because you’re from Messina.” back
  19. Xacca (modern Sciacca), Trapani, and Agrigento are on the south and west coasts of Sicily; Syracuse is on the east coast, south of Catania. back
  20. In the common speech antrachi, from the Greek anthrax, “coal,” meaning carbuncles, hard, dark, inflamed lumps in the flesh. back
  21. The body fluids (blood, phlegm, yellow bile, black bile) that medieval doctors believed had to stay in balance for health. back
  22. A priest needed his bishop’s permission to absolve some kinds of sin. Gerard governed Catania with a bishop’s powers as its administrator. He passed his full powers to every priest, so that no one need die unabsolved. back
  23. John of Aragon, duke of Athens and Neopatras, governed Sicily as vicar for his young nephew, King Louis. He died on April 3, 1348. back
  24. The belief that disease spread through foul or poisoned air. back
  25. Frederick III, king of Sicily from 1296 to 1337, the duke’s father. back
  26. Another gap in the printed text, marked by a row of dots. The lost words probably said what the mortality did to everyone. back