Hearth Interactive

A Hearth Library collection

Word for Word

Translators on their craft, from Cicero to the King James Bible and beyond

Should a translator carry the words or the sense? Writers have argued it for two thousand years, in prefaces, letters and handbooks. A companion to the Word for Word games on Hearth Games, which use the library's own checked translations to match phrases and words of the original to their English.

Games

Sources on the way

No sources are translated yet. These are planned, in rough date order.

  1. 46 BCE
    Not word for word, but as an orator

    Cicero, Rome, Latin.

  2. about 19 BCE
    The faithful translator

    Horace, Rome, Latin.

  3. 395
    Sense for sense

    Jerome, Bethlehem, Latin.

  4. 600s
    Five kinds of words not to translate

    Xuanzang (as reported by Zhou Dunyi), Chang'an, Classical Chinese.

  5. about 890
    Sometimes word for word, sometimes sense for sense

    King Alfred, Wessex, Old English.

  6. 1530
    Look at the mouth of the mother in the house

    Martin Luther, Coburg, German.

  7. 1611
    The Translators to the Reader

    Miles Smith and the King James translators, London, English.

  8. 1680
    Metaphrase, paraphrase and imitation

    John Dryden, London, English.

  9. 1791
    Three laws of translation

    Alexander Fraser Tytler, Edinburgh, English.

  10. 1898
    Faithful, clear and elegant

    Yan Fu, Tianjin, Classical Chinese.